args[0]=message
args[1]=DB::DB::Message=HASH(0x5883b90)
Re: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii
10.08.2007 0:34 | A. N. Churaev
Gospodin Yakimov! Ya prekrasno znayu sovremennye predstavleniya o stroenii Solnca i o teh reakciyah kotorye vnutri nego proishodyat. Ya takzhe vnimatel'no prochital ukazannuyu vami knigu Nasimovicha "Zvezdy". Kniga interesnaya i soderzhit informaciyu o tom kakie vidy zvezd na dannyi moment obnaruzheny, kak obnaruzhivayutsya zvezdy, kak sushestvuyushie teorii opisyvayut ih evolyuciyu i t.p. No ya nigde ne vstretil v knige kakogo-libo obosnovaniya odnorodnosti zvezd ili hotya by obosnovaniya togo chto himicheskii sostav Solnca takoi zhe kak i sostav ego poverhnosti. Nigde ne upominaetsya ni pro teorii, ni pro ekperimenty, kotorye mogli by prolit' svet na etot vopros. Ya takzhe ne ponimayu pochemu iz togo fakta chto na poverhnosti krasnogo giganta nahoditsya uglerod sleduet chto vodorod i gelii sgoreli vnutri zvezdy. Mozhet delo v tom chto iz-za nizkoi plotnosti zvezdy ona ne smogla uderzhat' vodorod i gelii i eti legkie elementy prosto uleteli s poverhnosti zvezdy? Vo vsyakom sluchae mnogie planety ne mogut uderzhat' legkie gazy. V chastnosti Zemlya ne uderzhivaet vodorod i gelii, a bednyaga Mars ne mozhet uderzhat' nichego krome uglekislogo gaza. A vot Yupiter uderzhivaet vse.
- "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (A. N. Churaev, 7.08.2007 11:40, 2.2 KBait, otvetov: 36)
- Re: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (Dmitrii Docenko, 7.08.2007 13:29, 932 Bait, otvetov: 4)
- Re[2]: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (A. N. Churaev, 7.08.2007 21:46, 1.9 KBait, otvetov: 3)
- Re[3]: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (M. Yu. Yakimov, 8.08.2007 0:52, 743 Bait, otvetov: 2)
- Re[4]: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (A. N. Churaev, 8.08.2007 10:34, 671 Bait, otvetov: 1)
- Re[5]: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (Dmitrii Docenko, 8.08.2007 12:25, 1.9 KBait)
- Re: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (A. N. Churaev, 8.08.2007 22:14, 901 Bait, otvetov: 1)
- Re[2]: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (Dmitrii Docenko, 9.08.2007 13:52, 651 Bait)
- Re: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (A. N. Churaev, 8.08.2007 22:31, 900 Bait)
- Re: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (A. N. Churaev, 8.08.2007 22:31, 900 Bait)
- Re: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (A. N. Churaev, 8.08.2007 23:05, 530 Bait, otvetov: 5)
- Re[2]: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (M. Yu. Yakimov, 8.08.2007 23:27, 1.2 KBait, otvetov: 4)
- Re[3]: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (A. N. Churaev, 9.08.2007 20:06, 1.2 KBait, otvetov: 2)
- Re[4]: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (M. Yu. Yakimov, 9.08.2007 20:47, 1.3 KBait)
- Re[n]: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (Dmitrii Docenko, 10.08.2007 14:20, 2.1 KBait)
- Re[3]: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (Karim Haidarov, 20.09.2008 8:37, 3.4 KBait)
- Re: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (A. N. Churaev, 9.08.2007 23:10, 1.2 KBait)
- Re: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (A. N. Churaev, 9.08.2007 23:11, 1.2 KBait)
- Re: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (A. N. Churaev, 9.08.2007 23:14, 1.2 KBait, otvetov: 1)
- Re[2]: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (M. Yu. Yakimov, 9.08.2007 23:30, 2.3 KBait)
- Re: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (A. N. Churaev, 9.08.2007 23:18, 67 Bait)
- >> Re: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (A. N. Churaev, 10.08.2007 0:34, 1.1 KBait, otvetov: 1)
- Re[2]: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (M. Yu. Yakimov, 10.08.2007 0:56, 966 Bait)
- Re: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (A. N. Churaev, 10.08.2007 0:50, 671 Bait)
- Re: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (A. N. Churaev, 10.08.2007 1:28, 1.2 KBait)
- Re: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (A. N. Churaev, 10.08.2007 9:29, 873 Bait)
- Re: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (A. N. Churaev, 10.08.2007 21:33, 4.3 KBait, otvetov: 1)
- Re[2]: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (Dmitrii Docenko, 11.08.2007 23:44, 3.9 KBait)
- Re: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (A. N. Churaev, 12.08.2007 13:19, 1.1 KBait, otvetov: 1)
- Re[2]: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (Dmitrii Docenko, 12.08.2007 16:58, 1.1 KBait)
- Re: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (A. N. Churaev, 12.08.2007 16:51, 1.2 KBait)
- Re: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (A. N. Churaev, 13.08.2007 21:43, 1.1 KBait, otvetov: 1)
- Re[2]: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (Dmitrii Docenko, 14.08.2007 12:31, 1.4 KBait)
- Re: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (A. N. Churaev, 14.08.2007 22:36, 1.0 KBait, otvetov: 3)
- Re[2]: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (M. Yu. Yakimov, 15.08.2007 0:24, 1.1 KBait, otvetov: 2)
- Re[3]: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (M. Yu. Yakimov, 15.08.2007 22:22, 116 Bait)
- Re[3]: "Volshebnye" principy astronomii (V. F. Pashkov, 19.09.2008 13:01, 5.2 KBait)