Peremennye Zvezdy

Peremennye Zvezdy (Variable Stars) 30, No. 2, 2010

Received 10 March; accepted 15 March.

Article in PDF

SN 2008fv: the Third Type Ia Supernova in NGC 3147

D. Yu. Tsvetkov1, L. Elenin2

  1. Sternberg Astronomical Institute, University Ave. 13, 119992 Moscow, Russia

  2. Keldysh Institute of Applied Mathematics RAS, Miusskaya sq. 4, 125047 Moscow, Russia


Multiple outbursts of type Ia SNe in one galaxy present a unique opportunity to study the homogeneity of these objects. NGC 3147 is only the second known galaxy with three SNe Ia, another one is NGC 1316. We present CCD photometry for SN Ia 2008fv and compare the light and color curves of this object to those for SNe Ia discovered in NGC 3147 earlier: 1972H and 1997bq. The photometric properties of SNe 1997bq and 2008fv are nearly identical, while SN 1972H exhibits a faster-declining light curve.

SN 2008fv

SN 2008fv was discovered by K. Itagaki on unfiltered CCD images exposed with a 0.6-m reflector around September 27.78 UT at magnitude 16.5. The new object was located at , (J2000.0), which is east and north of the center of the galaxy NGC 3147 (Nakano 2008).

Challis (2008), on behalf of the CfA Supernova Group, reported that a spectrum (range 350-880 nm) of SN 2008fv, obtained on September 30 with the MMT at Mt. Hopkins, showed it to be a normal type-Ia supernova about one week before maximum light. This is the fourth SN discovered in NGC 3147, the former were SN I 1972H (Goranskij 1972; Barbon et al. 1973), SN Ia 1997bq (Laurie and Challis 1997; Jha et al. 2006), and SN Ib 2006gi (Itagaki 2006; Elmhamdi et al. 2010).

We started photometric monitoring of SN 2008fv soon after its discovery, on October 3, with the remotely controlled telescope of the Tzec Maun Observatory. Later we also observed the SN with four other telescopes at three different locations. The data on the telescopes and detectors are presented in Table 1.

All image reductions and photometry were made using IRAF.1

The image of NGC 3147 obtained at C60 in the band is presented in Fig. 1. SN 2008fv and the sites of three previous SNe are marked, as well as the local standard stars. The magnitudes of these stars are reported in Table 2, they were calibrated on 12 photometric nights during monitoring SNe 2006gi and 2008fv. Stars 1 and 3 were also used as standards for the photometry of SN 2006gi (Elmhamdi et al. 2010).

SN 2008fv is projected on the spiral arm, and the subtraction of galaxy background is necessary for reliable photometry. The template images were constructed from frames obtained in November 2006 at C60 while monitoring SN 2006gi. After template subtraction, the magnitudes of the SN were derived by PSF fitting relative to a sequence of local standard stars.

Table 1: Telescopes and detectors used for observations
Telescope D(cm) F(cm) CCD camera Filters Location Code
Maksutov- 35 133 SBIG ST-10E Mayhill, New TM35
Newton         Mexico, USA  
Cassegrain 70 1050 Apogee AP-7p Moscow, Russia M70
Cassegrain 60 750 Apogee AP-47p Nauchny, Crimea, C60
          Ukraine  
Maksutov 50 200 Meade Pictor Nauchny, Crimea, C50
      416XT   Ukraine  
Newton 50 250 SBIG Tatranska Lomnica, S50
      ST-10XME   Slovakia  

Fig. 1. SN 2008fv in NGC 3147. Circles indicate the sites of previous SNe, the local standard stars are marked.

Table 2: Magnitudes of local standard stars
Star
1 13.88 0.05 13.40 0.01 12.58 0.01 12.12 0.01 11.75 0.01
2     14.91 0.02 14.15 0.02 13.71 0.01 13.37 0.03
3     17.28 0.05 16.43 0.04 15.95 0.03 15.45 0.04

The observations of SN 2008fv at TM35 in the filters are presented in Table 3, and the photometry in the filters obtained with other telescopes is reported in Table 4.

Table 3: Observations of SN 2008fv at TM35
JD 2454000+ JD 2454000+
742.86 14.89 0.03 14.73 0.02 773.93 15.36 0.03 15.12 0.06
746.92 14.56 0.02 14.44 0.02 776.86 15.57 0.03 15.16 0.02
747.90 14.52 0.02 14.43 0.01 777.85     15.18 0.01
748.91 14.47 0.02 14.36 0.01 778.98 15.65 0.03 15.23 0.01
749.91 14.47 0.02 14.37 0.02 779.98 15.71 0.03    
752.88 14.45 0.02 14.39 0.01 781.89 15.85 0.03 15.41 0.02
755.94 14.52 0.02 14.44 0.03 786.93 16.18 0.04 15.73 0.04
756.93 14.59 0.05 14.56 0.02 787.97 16.35 0.03 15.78 0.04
759.82 14.72 0.03 14.68 0.02 791.98 16.40 0.04 15.99 0.06
761.95 14.82 0.03 14.81 0.02 795.98 16.49 0.04 16.08 0.03
762.92 14.91 0.02 14.89 0.02 799.02 16.62 0.05 16.20 0.02
763.97 14.96 0.02 14.97 0.01 801.99 16.66 0.05 16.33 0.04
766.93 15.12 0.02 15.08 0.02 803.00 16.48 0.12 16.33 0.03
767.95 15.17 0.03 15.10 0.01 804.98     16.58 0.11
768.92 15.20 0.02 15.10 0.01 806.96 17.02 0.10 16.46 0.09
771.93 15.31 0.03 15.14 0.01          

Table 4: Observations of SN 2008fv at other telescopes
JD 2454000+ Tel.
755.33 14.89 0.07 14.89 0.03 14.37 0.03 14.41 0.02 14.65 0.07 M70
759.66 14.97 0.08 15.03 0.03 14.62 0.03 14.60 0.03 14.99 0.05 S50
778.45         15.56 0.03 15.20 0.02 14.80 0.05 C50
779.56     16.88 0.04 15.65 0.02 15.22 0.02 14.68 0.07 C60
780.49     17.00 0.04 15.70 0.02 15.31 0.02 14.78 0.03 C60
781.59     17.13 0.03 15.79 0.03 15.36 0.02 14.80 0.03 C60
782.41     17.05 0.04 15.86 0.03 15.44 0.02 14.81 0.04 C60
783.55     17.17 0.05 15.91 0.03 15.49 0.02 14.91 0.04 C60
784.49     17.25 0.07 15.94 0.03 15.56 0.02 14.96 0.05 C60
786.42     17.20 0.06 16.04 0.04 15.67 0.02 15.09 0.06 C60
795.36     17.67 0.04 16.47 0.03 16.14 0.02 15.60 0.05 C60
796.48     17.53 0.03 16.51 0.03 16.17 0.03 15.66 0.05 C60
799.41             16.28 0.05     S50
845.22             17.87 0.10     M70
866.21             18.08 0.09     M70
868.20             18.28 0.09     M70
894.36         18.98 0.06 18.90 0.07     M70

The light curves are shown in Fig. 2. The maximum phase in the and bands is well-sampled by the observations, and we can derive the dates and magnitudes of maximum light: on JD 2454752, on the same date. The rate of early decline in the band corresponds to . From the list of type Ia SNe presented by Hicken et al. (2009), we select three SNe with similar and best-observed light curves: 1992bc, 2006ax, 2007af (Hamuy et al. 1996; Hicken et al. 2009). We fit the light curves of SN 2008fv to those for the three SNe listed above and find that, in the band, the fits for all the three objects are equally good. In the band, SN 1992bc provides the best fit, while in the band, SN 2006ax gives the best result. The -band light curve cannot be fitted well by any of these SNe, but SN 2006ax provides a slightly better match.

Fig. 2. The light curves of SN 2008fv. Circles show data obtained at TM35, dots are for observations at other telescopes. The error bars are plotted only if they exceed the size of a symbol. The dashed lines are the light curves of SN 1992bc ( and bands) and SN 2006ax (